American Society of Ophthalmic Trauma Pilot · In development

Management by diagnosis  /  Herpes simplex and stromal keratitis

EmergencyQuick reference

Herpes simplex and stromal keratitis

A point of care reference for the clinician seeing the patient first, in the same four steps as Where Do I Start.

The first five minutes

  1. Look for vesicles around the eye. Check whether the rash extends beyond the eye and eyelids, or follows a dermatome, which points toward zoster.
  2. Check vision, pressure, and pupils. A large drop in vision or a high pressure suggests stromal disease or iritis.
  3. Stain with fluorescein and inspect the cornea at the slit lamp. Branching dendrites mean epithelial disease. A white, hazy cornea without dendrites suggests stromal disease.
  4. Remove contact lenses. In a contact lens wearer, a microbial infection must be considered.
  5. Start an oral antiviral today, and no steroid drops. Steroids treat stromal disease only when ophthalmology is directing therapy.
1

Pertinent questions when taking the history

  • When did the symptoms begin?
  • Have any treatments been tried? Did they improve the vision or the discomfort?
  • Is there a history of recurrent eye inflammation or infection?
  • Is there any history of HSV, or of unusual lesions or ulcers? If so, how often do recurrences occur?
  • Is the patient immunosuppressed?
  • Does the patient wear contact lenses? Lenses should be removed, and a microbial infection should be considered in any contact lens wearer.
2

Visual vital signs

Vision, pressure, and pupils, recorded and handed off like any other vital sign. Here they help separate surface disease from the deeper stromal and intraocular inflammation that costs vision.

Visual acuity

May be slightly to significantly decreased from baseline. The decline may be severe in stromal keratitis, where most of the corneal tissue is inflamed, thickened, and clouded.

Open near card →Video

Intraocular pressure

Mild elevations may be seen with corneal HSV. Significant elevations, 25 mmHg or higher, may come from inflammation of the eye's drainage network or iritis. A swollen cornea does not raise the pressure but can make Goldmann readings falsely low, so a Tono-Pen or iCare reading may be more reliable. Any elevation warrants ophthalmology consultation for acute management.

Video →

Pupillary exam

The affected pupil may be mildly constricted, with mild to severe light sensitivity, as is common in corneal conditions. These improve as the cornea heals. An afferent pupillary defect is not expected. If present, contact ophthalmology urgently.

Video
3

Describe the focused anatomy

Two different diseases share this name. HSV keratitis is viral infection of the corneal surface, the epithelium. Stromal keratitis is an inflammatory reaction to viral particles in the thick middle layer of the cornea, which swells and turns hazy, and it causes the greater loss of vision.

  • Eyelids and skinAre there ulcerations or vesicles on the lids?
  • ConjunctivaIs the affected eye injected?
  • Cornea, epithelial diseaseAre there raised, classic branching dendrites on the corneal epithelium after fluorescein? Are there white infiltrates associated with the dendrites? Recurrent disease can look atypical, with scattered or irregular dendrites.
  • Cornea, stromal diseaseIs there a white or gray haze in the stroma, or a swollen, cloudy cornea? Stromal and endothelial HSV often present without dendrites, and more often in a patient who has had herpetic eye episodes before. If the diagnosis is uncertain or a microbial infection is possible, arrange ophthalmology the same or next day. Suspicion for infection is higher after recent trauma and in contact lens wearers.
  • Anterior chamberIs it clear, or hazy with inflammatory debris? A hazy chamber may indicate iritis, which left untreated can lead to long term pupil abnormalities or cataract. Arrange ophthalmology within one day.
  • PupilDoes the pupil move, or does it appear static from synechiae, where inflammatory debris sticks the iris to the lens? For pain from iritis, one drop of a short acting cycloplegic such as cyclopentolate 1% is reasonable if the anterior chamber is not shallow. Leave atropine, which lasts up to two weeks, and any attempt to break synechiae to ophthalmology.
Photo montage
4

Supporting imaging, if needed

  • Usually noneHSV keratitis and HSV stromal keratitis are clinical diagnoses. Imaging is not usually required.
  • CT orbitsConsider if orbital signs or symptoms are present, such as an afferent pupillary defect, proptosis, restricted eye movements, or double vision, to rule out more diffuse disease.
5

Treatment

HSV keratitis

  • Oral antiviral, dendritic ulcerAcyclovir 400 mg three to five times daily, valacyclovir 500 mg twice daily, or famciclovir 250 mg twice daily, for 7 to 10 days.
  • Oral antiviral, larger geographic ulcerAcyclovir 800 mg five times daily, valacyclovir 1 g three times daily, or famciclovir 500 mg twice daily, for 14 to 21 days. Adjust every oral dose for renal function.
  • Topical antiviralGanciclovir 0.15% ophthalmic gel (Zirgan), one drop five times daily to the affected eye until the ulcer heals, then three times daily for 7 more days. One correctly dosed oral or topical agent is enough.

Stromal keratitis

  • Start the oral antiviral nowIf stromal keratitis is suspected, begin oral antiviral therapy at the point of care and arrange next day ophthalmology follow up for focused treatment recommendations.
  • Steroid drops wait for ophthalmologyStromal keratitis is treated with steroid drops together with an oral antiviral, usually for ten weeks or longer. Ophthalmology should start and taper the steroid after ruling out active epithelial infection at the slit lamp. A short delay for that visit does not worsen final vision.

Recurrent HSV

  • Treat the episodeA similar strategy to the first infection.
  • Topical corticosteroidUsed to treat stromal corneal inflammation and uveitis, the inflammation of the middle layers of the eye. Do not start unless the diagnosis is certain and ophthalmology is actively monitoring the condition.
  • Prophylaxis, decided by ophthalmologyAcyclovir 400 mg twice daily, valacyclovir 500 mg once daily, or famciclovir 250 mg twice daily, usually for at least a year, to reduce the frequency of recurrences. Higher doses are used in special cases such as after corneal transplant.
6

Follow up

  • IntervalOphthalmology follow up one to two days after the oral antiviral is started, to assess response.
  • SoonerEncourage more urgent follow up if stromal keratitis is present, the diagnosis is uncertain, or a topical corticosteroid is being considered. Make sure the oral antiviral is started at the initial point of care.
  • Contact lensesAvoid while the condition is being treated.
  • Protect othersHSV spreads through direct contact with eye secretions, saliva, or open lesions. Until any lid or lip lesions have crusted, the patient should wash hands often, avoid touching the eye, not share towels, and avoid kissing or close face to face contact with newborns and with people who have eczema, burns, or weakened immune systems. There is no vaccine for herpes simplex.
  • RecurrenceRecurrence is common in both HSV keratitis and stromal keratitis. Therapy to prevent recurrence should be discussed at outpatient ophthalmology follow up. Emphasize adherence to the treatment regimen and recognition of early symptoms.

Red flags

When a red flag is not explained by the examining clinician, consider additional consultation with ophthalmology for point of care triage guidance.

What the evidence says

Why steroid drops wait for ophthalmology

68%lower risk of stromal inflammation persisting or worsening with prednisolone drops compared with placebo. Every patient was also on an antiviral drop, so the steroid was never given alone.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 1994, Ophthalmology, randomized trial, 106 patients
6 monthsafter randomization, vision was no different in patients whose steroid was held for a few weeks of close observation. The delay slowed healing, but a short wait for ophthalmology to start the steroid did not cost final vision.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 1994, Ophthalmology
3 in 4patients had failed treatment by 16 weeks even on steroid and antiviral drops, and adding oral acyclovir did not change that rate, although more patients on acyclovir gained vision by 6 months. Stromal keratitis is a long, relapsing course.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 1994, Ophthalmology, randomized trial, 104 patients
Strongrecommendation from the Academy to treat epithelial HSV keratitis with antivirals alone and avoid steroid drops. In an older cohort, geographic ulcers were more likely to have been treated with a steroid and took longer to heal.American Academy of Ophthalmology treatment guideline 2014; Wilhelmus 1981, Archives of Ophthalmology, cohort, 152 patients

Steroid drops help stromal HSV, but only paired with an antiviral, only after an ophthalmologist has ruled out active epithelial infection at the slit lamp, and over a taper of ten weeks or longer. The trial data say a short wait for that visit is safe. A steroid started on an unrecognized epithelial infection or a mimic is the situation the guideline warns against.

Why recurrence prevention matters

32% to 19%was the drop in any herpetic eye recurrence over a year of oral acyclovir 400 mg twice daily, with no rebound in the six months after it stopped.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 1998, New England Journal of Medicine, randomized trial, 703 patients
28% to 14%was the drop in stromal recurrence among the 337 patients who had already had stromal keratitis. A follow up analysis found the stromal benefit was limited to these patients.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 1998 and 2000, New England Journal of Medicine and Archives of Ophthalmology
10 timesthe risk of another stromal episode followed a prior episode of stromal keratitis, and the risk rose with each past episode. A past epithelial episode did not predict more epithelial disease.Herpetic Eye Disease Study 2001, Cornea, placebo arm of a randomized trial, 346 patients
40,000new cases of severe vision loss or blindness in one eye each year are estimated worldwide from HSV keratitis, among roughly 1.5 million cases. The authors call this a conservative estimate.Farooq 2012, Survey of Ophthalmology, epidemiologic review

Recurrences, not the first episode, are what scar corneas, and patients with prior stromal disease gain the most from suppression. The first clinician does not need to start prophylaxis, but putting the history of past herpetic eye episodes in the referral lets ophthalmology make the call quickly.

Antivirals and mimics

RR 0.92for healing with oral acyclovir compared with a topical antiviral drop (95% CI 0.79 to 1.07), in the limited trials that tested it. Using an oral and a topical antiviral together has not been shown to speed healing.Wilhelmus 2015, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
77%of dendritic ulcers healed by day 7 with ganciclovir gel (Zirgan), compared with 72% with acyclovir ointment. The labeled course continues after day 7 when needed.Zirgan prescribing information, randomized trial, 164 patients
38%of Acanthamoeba keratitis cases at one referral center, and 37% at another, were first misdiagnosed as herpetic keratitis. Most patients wore contact lenses, and only 11% had the textbook ring infiltrate.Shah 2021, Acta Ophthalmologica, 43 patients; Höllhumer 2020, Eye, 52 patients
OR 3.9for a poor outcome in Acanthamoeba keratitis when a steroid drop was given before the correct diagnosis (95% CI 1.78 to 8.55), meaning vision 20/80 or worse, perforation, or transplant. The authors traced this mostly to the infection being mistaken for herpes.Robaei 2014, Ophthalmology, cohort, 196 patients

For epithelial HSV, one correctly dosed oral or topical antiviral is enough, and an oral agent can be started at the point of care when drops are not on hand. In a contact lens wearer, a dendrite like or slow healing keratitis should be treated as possible Acanthamoeba until ophthalmology has examined it, one more reason the steroid decision belongs to ophthalmology.

Additional resources

Where an ASOT resource covers this diagnosis in greater depth, it will be linked here.

Manual of Ophthalmic Emergencies and Trauma reference to be added on publication. In development

Written by Maddie Leung, BS. References pending author review. Draft for committee review.